Files
coder/docs/reference/api
Michael Suchacz af0ef00f91 feat: add owner_id to CreateChatRequest to create chats for another user (#29581)
Owners and owner-level service accounts can now start a Coder Agents
chat on behalf of another user by setting `owner_id` on `POST
/api/v2/chats`. The field is optional and defaults to the caller, so
existing clients are unaffected. A delegated owner must be an active,
non-system member of the requested organization; anything else returns
400 `Chat owner must be an active member of the organization.` once the
caller has passed the authorization gates below.

A chat runs entirely with its owner's credentials (synthetic API key,
workspace access, OIDC and provider tokens), so creating one for someone
else is acting as that user. On top of org-scoped `chat:create` for the
owner, the caller must hold the authority to create API keys for that
user, which is what the token endpoint demands to mint their session.
Org admins therefore cannot use it; site owners and owner-role service
accounts can. For the same reason the workspace binding, model config,
and MCP server IDs are validated as the owner rather than the caller,
and the owner must themselves hold `chat:create` (organization service
accounts do not). The initial user message is attributed to the caller
through `chatd.CreateOptions.CreatedBy`.

An earlier revision of this PR exposed the same behavior as `POST
/api/v2/users/{user}/chats`; that route and
`codersdk.Client.CreateUserChat` were removed in `62a8be3dd32` in favor
of the request field. An explicit zero `owner_id` is rejected with 400
rather than silently defaulting to the caller. Coverage lives in
`TestPostChats_OwnerID`.

<details>
<summary>Review record (path-based revision, gates unchanged)</summary>

- Two-axis code review (Standards, Spec) plus a simplicity audit ran as
Xum sub-agents on `1f3189898f0`. The Spec axis found the workspace
binding was authorized as the caller, fixed in `363d45281d8` with
red-green coverage in `WorkspaceNotAccessibleToOwner`. The additional
API-key gate and the `CreatedBy` attribution go beyond the workspaces
pattern and were kept deliberately for the reasons above.
- Codex review on `363d45281d8`: one P2, suspended, dormant, or system
users could be targeted and would get a chat that can never run because
AI Bridge refuses to authorize them. Fixed in `c065437e359` with
`OwnerSuspended` (red on the old head); thread replied to and resolved.
- Codex review on `c065437e359`: one P2, an explicit or
personal-override model config the caller can read but the owner cannot
was accepted and chatd would silently fall back to the default model at
run time. Fixed in `aa88b608182` by resolving the model config and MCP
server IDs under the owner's context, with
`ModelConfigNotAccessibleToOwner` (red on the old head); thread replied
to and resolved.
- Codex review on `aa88b608182`: one P2, an organization service account
(which deliberately holds no chat permissions) could be targeted because
the chat permission check ran as the caller. Fixed in `a6fe8075c30` by
also requiring the owner subject to hold `chat:create`, with
`OwnerWithoutChatPermission` (red on the old head); thread replied to
and resolved.
- Codex review on `a6fe8075c30`: one P2, the active/non-system check was
skipped when the caller could not read the owner's user object. Fixed in
`0dd8bb4dd44` by moving the check behind the authorization gates with a
system-restricted lookup; thread replied to and resolved. In
`62a8be3dd32` that lookup became a single `OrganizationMembers` query,
which also covers membership and excludes system and deleted users.
- Codex review on `62a8be3dd32` (the `owner_id` revision): two P2s. An
explicit zero `owner_id` was treated as omitted and created the chat for
the caller; fixed in `f54b4f33d36` with a 400 and `OwnerIDNil` (red on
the old head). Creation and the read-back still ran as the caller while
the preflight ran as the owner; fixed in the same commit by passing
`ownerCtx` to `CreateChat`, `GetChatByID`, title generation, and the
file-metadata fetch. That second scenario is unreachable today (only the
built-in `owner` role holds `api_key:create` for others, and site-wide
custom roles are refused by both the API and dbauthz), so it has no
dedicated red test. Both threads replied to and resolved.
</details>

<details>
<summary>Remote UAT record (path-based revision)</summary>

Remote UAT on dogfood (chat `d7442df3-693f-4403-805f-2de52f7bdbed`, Xum
sub-agent as critical runner) tested head `21ed6b389cc`, the last
path-based revision. Licensed dev server, real Haiku 4.5 model, 77
logged API requests, 23 inspected screenshots. Endorsed verdict:
**PASS**. Site owner creates a chat for member X: X sees it, gets real
answers to the admin prompt and to follow-ups, and state survives reload
and mid-response refresh. The creating admin gets `403 Only the chat
owner may send messages.` and a read-only view; an unrelated member gets
404. Org admin, member, user-admin, and template-admin callers get 403;
owner-role service account 201. Suspended, dormant, and service-account
targets 400; owner-inaccessible workspace, model config, or MCP server
400; 300 KiB body 413. The `owner_id` revision changes only how the
owner is supplied and the non-member response (400 instead of 404); the
authorization and eligibility gates it exercised are unchanged and
covered by `TestPostChats_OwnerID`.

Non-blocking findings for the author's judgment, none of them
regressions of this PR:
1. X's UI shows no author on the admin-written first message and offers
X "Edit" on it; `created_by` carries the admin but the frontend does not
surface it.
2. A site owner who is not a member of the organization can still create
a chat for its members (201), while a self-owned `POST /chats` returns
403 for the same organization; same asymmetry as `postUserWorkspaces`.
3. The creating admin can archive, rename, and interrupt X's chat
although it cannot message it (pre-existing chat authz).
4. Owner-inaccessible model config or MCP server is reported as "not
found or disabled" with no hint that the owner, not the caller, lacks
access.
5. Dormant (never logged in) targets are refused because AI Bridge
rejects non-active users; a new hire cannot be given a chat until first
login.
6. The endpoint docs list only 201 and 413.
</details>

> Xum (an AI agent) acted on behalf of @ibetitsmike for this PR.
2026-09-21 20:49:10 +02:00
..